Man shot multiple times by Indio police convicted in mobile home shooting
A Coachella man who was shot eight times by an Indio police officer after firing off a gun at a Coachella mobile home park was found guilty today of two felonies.
Jurors deliberated for nearly two days before convicting Mario Alberto Soto, 43, of shooting at an inhabited dwelling and negligent discharge of a firearm in connection with the Nov. 13, 2014, gunfire at the Coachella Mobile Home Park.
Jurors deadlocked 11-1 in favor of guilt on a felony count of brandishing a firearm in the presence of Indio police Officer Christopher Shannon.
The officer was cleared in the shooting by the Riverside County District Attorney’s Office.
Authorities converged on the mobile home park after Soto fired a gun, with one bullet entering a neighboring home in the early morning hours. No one was struck by the gunfire.
Sheriff’s deputies and Indio police found Soto’s trailer on fire, then saw him drive off in a Ford Mustang, according to Deputy District Attorney John Rodnick. The Mustang was later found abandoned, with a .380-caliber handgun inside, he said.
Soto was later approached by Shannon on Dr. Carreon Boulevard, and as the officer approached him, Soto pulled a handgun from his waistband, prompting Shannon to respond with gunfire, according to police.
Soto was struck by bullets, then fell or jumped into bushes, and was shot during a second volley of gunfire because he wouldn’t drop his gun, according to the prosecutor.
Defense attorney Leonard Cravens maintained that Soto never fled from officers and never pointed the gun — which was unloaded — at Shannon, nor did he understand that Shannon was a police officer. The attorney said Shannon arrived on scene and demanded that Soto “Show me your hands,” a command Soto was unable to understand as he primarily speaks Spanish.
Cravens also said Soto was turned away from Shannon, preventing him from leveling the gun at the officer, who he accused of lying about what happened.
“Officer Shannon’s covering up what he did,” Cravens said. “Mr. Soto didn’t point a gun at him.”
Rodnick told jurors that Shannon did what was necessary to protect himself, and emphasized the tension of a situation in which officers are searching for an armed suspect.
“It is insulting to say that it was Officer Shannon who was out of control,” Rodnick told the jury. “To argue that (Soto) is a victim is a disservice to the people who suffered in this incident.”
The prosecutor argued that Soto “caused this situation at each and every stage,” while Cravens disputed whether there was proof that Soto fired off the initial shots that prompted the police investigation.
Cravens said ballistics testing was never performed to determine whether Soto’s gun matched the bullets at the mobile home park, while Rodnick said spent casings matching the same type of gun were found near Soto’s trailer, and that the defendant confessed to the shooting while interviewed at a hospital following surgery.
Rodnick said Soto told officers he’d been on drugs and was depressed about a recent separation from his wife, but Cravens said little credible evidence could be derived from the “so-called confession” at the hospital, as Soto was just coming out of major surgery.
Cravens alleged that Soto had no motive to point an unloaded gun at Shannon other than to commit suicide by cop, a theory that was never advanced by prosecutors.
Since the shooting, Soto filed an excessive force federal lawsuit against Shannon, the Indio Police Department and the city of Indio. Prior to the trial, Riverside County Superior Court Judge James Hawkins ruled that the jury would not be allowed to hear any references to the lawsuit.
Soto’s next court hearing — a date was not immediately available — will determine whether a new trial will be sought by prosecutors on the charge of brandishing a firearm.
Download the KESQ & CBS Local 2 app on iTunes or Google Play for up-to-the-minute breaking news alerts & more
More: I-Team and Stands for You investigations
Find us on Facebook: KESQ News Channel 3 & CBS Local 2
Follow us on Twitter for breaking news updates: @KESQ & @Local2
We’re on Instagram! @KESQ_News_Channel_3 & @CBSLocal2
Noticias en español: Telemundo 15
